The old way
On Saturday I went to the post office to send a gift to friends in the U.S.
It had been three or four years since I’d mailed a parcel. Back then, the routine was simple. Hand over the parcel. They weigh it, measure it. You fill out a little paper customs form, they stick it on the box, and off it goes. Ten minutes, start to finish. Twenty if there was a lineup.
You can probably guess where this is going.
The new way
The young woman at the Canada Post counter was genuinely lovely. She clearly knew what she was doing, and nothing that follows is her fault.
She told me the price, which was eye-watering, but that’s a whole other story. Then she handed me a piece of paper with a QR code on it. Turns out, they don’t do the old-fashioned paper forms anymore. Huh. Ok. To send my parcel today, I’ll just need to quickly install an app on my phone. Not a Canada Post app, mind you. A third-party app. And then I needed to enter all the sender and receiver information, the contents, the value, all of it, and hit submit.
I didn’t want yet another app on my phone, so I chose the second option: poke the huge, complicated, tiny-fonted URL into my phone’s browser.
Did I mention I didn’t have my glasses? Why would I? I was going to be there for ten minutes and fill out a few lines on a familiar form. But I digress.
So there I am, squinting at my phone at the counter, typing in everything I used to write on a simple paper form. There are now two people in line behind me, and my husband is texting me from the parking lot “Everything ok?”
Twenty minutes in, I finally hit submit, and the screen tells me with great certainty that I owe $120 in duty. On a gift.
I go back to the counter and ask the lovely young lady why. And she says, “Oh, shoot. Yeah, that happens all the time. Want me to do it for you?”
That happens all the time.
So she takes my phone and spends another ten minutes filling out the form again herself, while two people wait behind me. At this point, I can’t even look at them, as the humiliation of not being able to complete a simple task is becoming a bit overwhelming. Then she turns the screen around with a big smile. “We did it!” Zero dollars. Done.
Thirty-five minutes at the counter, for something that used to take ten, at roughly 50% more than I used to pay, for the slowest shipping option they offer because the faster options are simply ridiculous. Good times.
End-stage enshittification is here
Several times a week, people call me a “techie.” I figure out technology and teach other people how to figure it out for a living. Did I mention I have been on the internet since before most of it existed? I am not new at this.
And I could not get that form right.
That’s not a me problem, that’s a system problem. And if it “happens all the time,” it’s not a bug.
You see, the amount of work to achieve the task of providing information to a customs declaration has not disappeared. People in customs offices all over the place used to process the information that we wrote on the piece of paper that was stuck to the package. Now, that work has been transferred to us. Actually, not transferred - forced.
The organizations to whom we pay exorbitant costs to handle shipping, customs, billing, booking, and customer support, have taken the labour they used to handle and handed it to us, through an app, a portal, a chatbot, a QR code. Oh yeah, and they keep raising the price, citing declining usage of their system.
So, now, in this technologically advanced society we live in, we get to pay more and do all the work.
Cory Doctorow gave this a name: enshittification. Platforms start out good for users, then squeeze users to serve business customers, then squeeze everyone to serve themselves.
I used to think of it as just a social media thing but it isn’t anymore. It’s infiltrated the post offices, the banks, the airlines, the utilities, the doctor’s office booking systems, and the parking meters that only take payment through an app.
The new unpaid internship
I started thinking about how much time I spend on the technology I’m being forced to manage just to live my life these days. I spend literally hours a week just setting up accounts, resetting passwords, navigating portals and filling out forms that used to be someone’s actual job.
I’d guess five to ten hours a week. For real. (I really should time it.)
That’s a part-time, unpaid job. And I’m someone who’s actually good at this tech stuff. What about my non-techie neighbour who’s 92? What about the person who doesn’t own a smartphone, or can’t afford the data plan, or doesn’t read English well, or, like me on Saturday, just forgot their glasses?
Some days it makes me want to throw every device I own out the window, and I know I’m not the only one.
Who owns the app?
Here’s the kicker of the whole thing. Canada Post didn’t send me to its own app for the customs declaration, it sent me to a third-party app. So my name, my address, my recipient’s name and address, what I was sending and what it was worth all went... where, exactly? To whom? Stored on whose servers, in what country?
Arlene Dickinson just published a piece on her Substack, I might have been wrong about data centres. She’s been a vocal critic of data centres, but she’s rethinking it (as am I). Her point is that it’s not enough for our data to sit in Canada. We need to ask who owns the buildings it sits in and the computers it runs on, because right now a lot of that belongs to foreign companies that answer to foreign governments. Her line that stuck with me: if we don’t own any of that, we’re just tenants in our own country.
So let’s break down what is really happening here. We pay more for the service now, and we get to do the work ourselves. Our personal information gets handed to a company we never chose, running on infrastructure we don’t own. All while living in a country where a lot of people can barely afford groceries and rent, let alone another subscription.
That’s not progress. That’s a really bad deal disguised as convenience.
So what do we do?
I’m done just grumbling about it. Here’s where I think we start.
Name it. Every time you’re asked to do a company’s work for them, say so. Out loud, at the counter, in the review, in the survey they’ll inevitably send you via yet another QR code that goes to another website that collects your data. “This used to be your job” is a perfectly polite sentence.
Ask for the human option, and use it. If there’s still a paper form or a human who can help, choose that. Every time. If we all stop using the human option, the human option disappears.
Write to your elected officials. Your MP. Your MPP. Your city councillor. Canada Post is a Crown corporation. That means it answers to us. Tell them that public services should be accessible to everyone, not just people with the latest phone and perfect eyesight. Ask what they’re doing about it. Ask who owns the apps and the infrastructure our public services now run on. Then keep asking, and keep demanding that things change.
Show up. Town halls. Public consultations. Protests. The people deciding how our services work are counting on us being too tired and too busy to push back.
Talk about it. With friends, with family, here in the comments. Half the power of this whole thing is that each of us thinks we’re the only one who can’t figure out the form, and that is simply not true.
You’re not. I teach this stuff, and I couldn’t either.
(I wanted to explain this to the very patient folks in line behind me at the post office, but I was too embarrassed).
Enshittification is unacceptable. Let’s start saying so.
Have you had your own “that happens all the time” moment? Tell me about it in the comments.


